« Home | Why So Many "Eyes" » | A Fast Shabbos » | When Redemption Costs - Answer » | An Interesting Question - Two Interesting Answers » | Redemption Costs » | Pro-Creation: Answer » | A Rebbe For Torah Only? » | An Interesting Question » | Obesity » | Signs »

Riddle-In : A Riddle Designed To Keep You "Focused" On Torah - A Shofarian Anomaly

What would be a scenario where we would have a shofar that is kosher for all intents and purposes [nobody vowed not to derive benefit, wasn't ever used for Avodah Zara etc.] yet it would be kosher for Reuvain and unkosher for Shimon. [Riddle heard from the Tolna Rebbe Shlita.]

Hint: The answer could be found after a CAREFUL reading of the Biur Halacha in Simman 586.

Bonus: What Rosh Hashana word equals exactly 586?

shofar------- what do i win?

A great wife and baby [and more to come]. A meal at the Ehrmans. A lifetime friendship with me [hope that's a prize]. A bracha for a ksiva vichasima tova!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I didn't see the source cited, but what about a שופר owned by ראובן where שמעון is מודר הנאה from ראובן? Or would we say there that the קול is the חפצא, just like אין בקול דין גזל?

Post a Comment

Powered by WebAds
Segula - 40 days at the Kotel

About me

  • I'm Rabbi Ally Ehrman
  • From Old City Jerusalem, Israel
  • I am a Rebbe in Yeshivat Netiv Aryeh.
My profile